Smithfield's Best Restaurant

I’m not going to pretend I found the only places worth eating in Smithfield, because that would ignore the fact that I ate my body weight in mac and cheese at 815 Gourmet Grill and then chased it with homemade ice cream at Celtic Creamery. Smithfield has always been a stop for gas and a biscuit on the way to the coast, but the actual sit-down game here is absurdly strong, from the quiet wine pours at The Vine to the buffet at Robbins Nest that requires a strategy session beforehand.

You’ve got Thai curries that hold their own against any city kitchen and a whole hog operation that runs tighter than my apartment. I checked the sanitation grades, because I’m that person.

Here’s where to eat when you’re actually hungry.

Barley and Burger Smashed

Highlights
Hot, fresh, seasoned food
Friendly, attentive staff service
Generous portions, fair prices
Great fries, tots, and sides
Worth a return visit

I walked into Barley and Burger Smashed with low expectations, mostly because I had already eaten twice that day. The food came out hot and fresh, which sounds like a low bar until you realize how often restaurants miss it. The seasoned fries and tots were excellent. Portions are generous, prices are fair, and the staff treated me like a regular even though I clearly forgot how to order. I left full, slightly embarrassed, and already planning a return visit. That is the highest compliment I can give any restaurant.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Apex.

The Gilded Pear

Highlights
Great coffee and atmosphere
Spacious yet cozy seating
Full menu beyond coffee
Prompt, pleasant service

The Gilded Pear is the kind of place where I could sit for hours and pretend I am working. The coffee is solid, and the atmosphere is spacious enough that I did not feel guilty about taking up a table with my notebook. They have a full menu beyond coffee, which I appreciated because I was hungry and my willpower is weak. Service was prompt and pleasant, which matters more to me than it should. I left caffeinated, fed, and mildly resentful that I had to go back to real life.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Garner.

Origin Thai Bar & Cuisine

Highlights
Friendly staff, cozy space
Excellent vegan options available
High sanitation grade earned
Delicious Thai curries and noodles
Worth a visit anytime

Origin Thai Bar & Cuisine caught me off guard. I expected decent Thai food, but I did not expect the staff to be so friendly or the space to feel so cozy. The curries and noodles were delicious, and I noticed they had excellent vegan options, which I did not need but respect. They also earned a high sanitation grade, which for me is a bonus because I have a habit of checking those. I will visit again, probably sooner than my waistline would prefer.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Fayetteville.

The Vine at TBA

Highlights
Friendly, knowledgeable bartender service
Delicious wines and charcuterie
Tasty, well-portioned sandwiches
Quiet, relaxed Saturday atmosphere

The Vine at TBA was quiet on Saturday, which is exactly what I wanted. The bartender knew their wines and talked me through the charcuterie without making me feel like a novice. The sandwiches were tasty and well-portioned, which is rare in a wine bar. I did not feel rushed or judged for lingering. The relaxed atmosphere made it easy to pretend I was sophisticated for an hour. I left with a slight buzz and a newfound respect for cured meats.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Holly Springs.

815 Gourmet Grill N Commissary

Highlights
Worth the return trip
Huge portions, messy sandwiches
Mac and cheese shines
Jack provides standout service
Counter order, self-serve drinks

815 Gourmet Grill N Commissary is not for the faint of heart or the small of stomach. The portions are huge, and the sandwiches are messy in the best way. The mac and cheese is the star, and I say that knowing the sandwiches are the main event. Jack, who worked the counter, gave standout service, which made the experience better. You order at the counter and grab your own drink. I will absolutely make the return trip, and I will bring a napkin bigger than my arm.

You might also want to check out the best food in Fayetteville.

Robbins Nest

Highlights
Soul food worth the wait
Massive buffet, homemade desserts
Friendly, welcoming staff
Feels like a family reunion

Robbins Nest serves soul food that made me forget I was in Smithfield and not at my grandmother's house. The buffet is massive, and I tried to be sensible but failed. The homemade desserts are worth the embarrassment of going back for seconds. The staff welcomed me like family, and I left feeling like I had attended a reunion for people I did not know. The wait was worth it, and I say that as someone who hates waiting for anything.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Clayton.

Curry Corner Indian Cuisine

Highlights
Fresh, flavorful dishes every time
Friendly, attentive, knowledgeable staff
Bright, clean, open dining space
Accommodating with food allergies
Warm, inviting atmosphere throughout

Curry Corner Indian Cuisine is bright, clean, and open, which is not how I usually describe Indian food. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, and they handled my food allergy with care, which I appreciated more than they know. Every dish tasted fresh and flavorful. The dining space is warm and inviting, and I did not want to leave. If you have allergies, they will accommodate you without making it weird. I left full, satisfied, and slightly afraid of the spice level I chose.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Lillington.

White Swan BBQ

Highlights
Whole hog catering for crowds
Linwood runs a tight crew
Fresh sides and hushpuppies served
Eastern NC BBQ done right
Big events handled with ease

White Swan BBQ is the real deal for Eastern North Carolina barbecue. Linwood runs a tight crew, and you can tell because everything runs smoothly even when the place is packed. The whole hog catering is impressive, and they handled a big event I attended with ease. The sides and hushpuppies were fresh, and the barbecue was done right. I did not have to ask for anything twice. That is rare, and I have eaten at a lot of barbecue joints.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurant in Fayetteville.

Under the Oak Catering

Highlights
Reliable for years, repeatedly
Delicious food, raved by guests
Handles allergies with care
Thoughtful service for all
Efficient setup and breakdown

Under the Oak Catering has been reliable for years, and I keep coming back because they keep delivering. The food is delicious, and my guests have raved about it every time. They handle allergies with care, which is a big deal for me because I have a friend with a laundry list of restrictions. The service is thoughtful, and the setup and breakdown are efficient. I have used them repeatedly, and I will use them again. That says more than any review I could write.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Hope Mills.

Celtic Creamery JOCO

Highlights
Homemade ice cream, kind owner
Unique recipes, onsite preparation
Apple pie, berry flavors
Mini donuts worth return

Celtic Creamery JOCO makes homemade ice cream with recipes I have not seen anywhere else. The owner is kind and clearly cares about what they do. I tried the apple pie and berry flavors, and both were excellent. The mini donuts are worth the return trip on their own. I watched them make the ice cream onsite, which felt like a science experiment I was allowed to eat. I left with a sugar high and no regrets.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Clinton.

Parkside Cafe

Highlights
Clean, friendly, prompt service
Moist grilled chicken, hot food
Great cheeseburger, extensive menu
Independent, down-home atmosphere
Worth returning for lunch

Parkside Cafe is the kind of independent place that makes me want to move to Smithfield for the lunch options. The service was clean, friendly, and prompt. The grilled chicken was moist, and the food came out hot. I had the cheeseburger, and it was great. The menu is extensive, and the atmosphere is down-home without feeling dated. I will return for lunch, and I will probably order the same thing because I am a creature of habit.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Selma.

Massimo Pizza

Highlights
Best pizza in area
Family-owned, welcoming service
Fresh, worth the wait
Wheelchair accessible and clean
Better value than chains

Massimo Pizza is the best pizza in the area, and I say that with some authority because I have eaten a lot of pizza. The family-owned operation makes you feel welcome from the moment you walk in. The pizza is fresh, and it is worth the wait. The place is wheelchair accessible and clean, which is more than I can say for some places I have visited. It is a better value than any chain, and I left with a full stomach and a light wallet. I will be back, probably sooner than I should.

You might also want to check out the best bakery in Fayetteville.